Colour was perfect and it’s a liquid felt type product. Others I’ve tried in the past turn orange or smudge and this doesn’t which is amazing!!! The tip was fine and perfect for doing hair line strokes. BUT……the tip literally had no product after doing just one eyebrow. It has turned white and while there’s still product at the base it doesn’t reach the tip so it really is useless now. While standing it up to hope it drains back down may work it will still only do one eyebrow at a time. Absolutely gutted. 2 stars because my one eyebrow did look great haha and the formula looked and felt amazing