Released in 1974 after King Crimson had “ceased to exist”, Red remains a remarkably powerful document of a group quitting at the top of its game. The grinding crunch of Red appears to anticipate much of the heavy metal scene whilst the epic Starless brings together several strands of the group’s musical history.
Including powerful contributions from Ian McDonald, Mel Collins, David Cross, Mark Charig and Robin Miller, Red forms what is arguably the definitive statement of the ‘70s period Crimson. Bill Bruford recently described the album in just five words: Prescient, short and bass heavy.”
Review:
King Crimson fell apart once more, seemingly for the last time, as David
Cross walked away during the making of this album. It became Robert
Fripp's last thoughts on this version of the band, a bit noiser overall but
with some surprising sounds featured, mostly out of the group's past – Mel
Collins' and Ian McDonald's saxes, Marc Charig's cornet, and Robin
Miller's oboe, thus providing a glimpse of what the 1972-era King Crimson
might've sounded like handling the later group's repertory (which nearly
happened). Indeed, Charig's cornet gets just about the best showcase it ever
had on a King Crimson album, and the truth is that few intact groups could have
gotten an album as good as Red together. The fact that it was put together by a
band in its death throes makes it all the more impressive an achievement.
Indeed, Red does improve in some respects on certain aspects of the previous
album – including “Starless,” a cousin to the prior album's title
track – and only the lower quality of the vocal compositions keeps this from
being as strongly recommended as its two predecessors.
Bruce Eder, AllMusic.com