Jeff and Heather were the “Lucky ones.” They were inseparable soul mates. Over time, however, Jeff became a workaholic, and Heather felt the neglect. After the birth of their son, Ethan, and with Jeff never around, Heather fell into a deep depression. In a moment of despair, Heather made the life-altering decision to leave Jeff for the night – and never returned. After police searches, missing person's reports, and endless efforts to find her, she was gone.

Ten years later – life has moved on for Jeff and Ethan. Jeff is on the verge of proposing to Katie, his girlfriend of eight months, and Ethan has grown into a well-adjusted eleven year old. While not forgotten, Heather is a vivid, but distant memory of the past for Jeff, and no memory at all for Ethan.

Jeff is befriended by Dave, a fellow regular at a local coffee house. After striking up a friendship, they learn that their sons are baseball little league teammates. With summer break approaching, Dave encourages Jeff to allow Ethan to come to “Kids Fest”, a fun, week-long kid's summer event at Dave's church. Ambivalent toward God and church, but feeling that Kids Fest would be – if nothing else – good babysitting for his son, Jeff accepts.

Ethan has a blast, and on the final day, Jeff and Katie are persuaded to attend a brief show, which the kids are performing. It is on this day that Jeff receives the monumental shock of his life. Heather, who is now a committed Christian, is one of the Kids Fest helpers!

Jeff is forced to wrestle with forgiveness, reconciliation, and the irresistible grace of God.