After several relationships failed for the same reason, High School Senior Monica Readdie believes she can't experience romantic love. She isn't the popular girl in class, but she isn't the outcast either. Finding her niche as the choir's pianist, Monica is comfortable surrounded by her music and friends.Five years removed from personal tragedy, Lillian Starr is in a new school ready to meet new people. A gifted musician herself, Lillian joins the choir and tries out to be the pianist. There are two problems with her plan: the job already belongs to Monica, and they have a tainted history.When the choir director asks the two of them to work together, their former rivalry resurfaces and Monica starts feeling emotions she never thought possible.