Computers & Internet Books:

Bayesian Network Analysis of Evidence in Criminal Court Cases

Format

Hardback

Customer rating

Click to share your rating 0 ratings (0.0/5.0 average) Thanks for your vote!

Share this product

Bayesian Network Analysis of Evidence in Criminal Court Cases by Ka-Sze Hayson Tse
Unavailable
Sorry, this product is not currently available to order

Description

This dissertation, "Bayesian Network Analysis of Evidence in Criminal Court Cases" by Ka-sze, Hayson, Tse, 謝家樹, was obtained from The University of Hong Kong (Pokfulam, Hong Kong) and is being sold pursuant to Creative Commons: Attribution 3.0 Hong Kong License. The content of this dissertation has not been altered in any way. We have altered the formatting in order to facilitate the ease of printing and reading of the dissertation. All rights not granted by the above license are retained by the author. Abstract: When justice goes wrong, grave consequences entail. They are damaging to the standing of the legal system and people's lives. Humans are not good at assessing uncertainties. Parties to a legal proceeding adduce evidence to support or reject hypotheses. Errors happen when the tribunal fails to consider properly all the evidence in the context of inherent probabilities or improbabilities. This research work does not advocate trials by mathematics or statistics. This work extends the understanding of the application of Bayesian Networks in the law domain. The original contribution to knowledge is the analysis of evidence by Bayesian Network in the context of specific legal requirements of Hong Kong. The research questions are: 1. What are the legal requirements for the analysis of evidence in a criminal trial in Hong Kong?2. How can a Bayesian Network be constructed for the purpose of such analysis?3. Is such a Bayesian Network effective for the analysis? In answering the questions, this research work examined the feasibility of generic models created for digital crime scene investigations and concluded that each case must be, for the purpose of analysis of evidence in the trial, represented by a different Bayesian Network. This research work examined the trial processes, the tasks of tribunal of facts of criminal trials and some appellate decisions in Hong Kong. The work also created models of reasoning processes for the juries in Hong Kong. The work then compared the properties of Bayesian Networks with the processes of evaluation of evidence during trials. This research work also considered the reluctance of courts in the United Kingdom to allow experts to express their opinions on the bases of Bayesian calculations; even though trials are practically evaluations of uncertainties and assignments of degrees of beliefs. This research work then constructed a schedule of levels of proof and proposed a schematic method, to be used with the schedule, to construct Bayesian Networks for any types of trial in Hong Kong. The method requires an analyst to go through a mass of evidence systematically, and analyse their relationships amongst the ultimate probandum, the penultimate probanda, the intermediate propositions, the facts in issue and the facts relevant to the issue. This work then demonstrated the applications by two criminal cases in Hong Kong. The analyses show that the construction of Bayesian Network by the schematic method enables an analyst to take precaution to reach an assessment rationally and to approximate as far as capable his or her belief to the facts in issue. Subjects: Evidence, Criminal - China - Hong KongBayesian statistical decision theory - Data processing
Release date NZ
January 27th, 2017
Contributor
Created by
Illustrations
colour illustrations
Country of Publication
United States
Imprint
Open Dissertation Press
Dimensions
216x279x16
ISBN-13
9781361381298
Product ID
26643283

Customer reviews

Nobody has reviewed this product yet. You could be the first!

Write a Review

Marketplace listings

There are no Marketplace listings available for this product currently.
Already own it? Create a free listing and pay just 9% commission when it sells!

Sell Yours Here

Help & options

  • If you think we've made a mistake or omitted details, please send us your feedback. Send Feedback
  • If you have a question or problem with this product, visit our Help section. Get Help
Filed under...

Buy this and earn 853 Banana Points