Newly single food critic and newspaper reporter Traci Hightower is done with dating. After the man of her dreams left her at the altar on their wedding day and ran off with the woman she thought was her best friend, Traci resolves to focus on work and resigns herself to being a bachelorette for life. Marc Roberts is a political reporter who is known as Mr. Nice Guy, the one who always finishes last. However, Marc's compassion and kindness are of invaluable help to his newly widowed sister Gina Braxton who is trying to raise her two kids in the wake of her firefighter husband's death. Traci and Marc may be the perfect match, but they don't know it yet. With God's guidance and the help of Gina's matchmaking skills honed by her career as a bestselling romance novelist, there is hope for a happily ever after for these two broken hearts.