"Negative criticism not justified."
This game is fun, true Duke fans will enjoy the old Dukeisms and the attitude of the game, familiar enemies and weapons. The bonus of some driving levels add something different.
There is a reasonably easy 1000G up for grabs in the X360 version of the game if that interests you, 1205G if you purchase The Doctor Who Cloned Me DLC, and no multiplayer achievements. A couple of mini games can be a bit of a grind if you are going for achievements but these are not as bad as some other games.
At least two playthroughs are required if you are after all the gamer score as the insane difficulty doesn't unlock until one playthrough on any level is completed. There can be a couple of challenging boss fights on insane but nothing that can't be beaten with the right methods.
The multiplayer levels add some extra entertainment as long as you get good timing to find others online of course.
Overall if you are a Duke fan from way back, or you are open to Dukes quirks and attitude this game is well worth playing. Graphics and sound are pretty good, no noticable slow downs or glitches when I played.
Just a note for those installing the game on the X360 hard drive, you may need to sign out of any profiles for the install to work.